Yesterday had a second interview with a MM Investment Bank, and they asked me to let them know an expiration date of my offer. The majority of Private Credit groups will administer a case study as the next portion of the interview process. Ive signed a IB return offer after the summer internship in a top MM in Asia (Hong Kong / Singapore) but now get an opportunity to interview with a mid tier BB (Citi/Baml/CS) in the same city. Ahead of much more "qualified" (whatever that means) candidates. Yes this makes sense. While at the MSA program, I also applied to MS in Finance programs after I had accepted the offer from a Big 4. If they cant guarantee a full-time conversion and its very specialized, then yes, DCM may be better. It is a BB. what should I do? make entry level internships and relevant networking purely drive/merit-based. I was talking to people and they seemed to be one two different ends. 101 Investment Banking Interview Questions, Certified Investment Advisor Professional - Partner, Certified Hedge Fund Professional - Research Analyst, Certified Private Equity Professional - 2nd Year Associate, Certified Venture Capital Professional - Director, Certified Private Equity Professional - Vice President, Certified Private Equity Professional - 3rd+ Year Associate, Certified Investment Banking Professional - 2nd Year Analyst, Certified Private Equity Professional - 1st Year Associate, Certified Investment Banking Professional - 1st Year Associate, Private Equity Interview Questions To Ask, Certified Investment Banking Professional - 1st Year Analyst, Financial Modeling & Valuation 2-Day Bootcamp OPEN NOW - Only 15 Seats, Venture Capital 4-Hour Bootcamp - Sat April 1st - Only 15 Seats, Excel Master 4-Hour Bootcamp OPEN NOW - Only 15 Seats, Venture Capital 4-Hour Bootcamp - Sat May 20th - Only 15 Seats. What do you think about accepting one of the biglaw offers, proceeding with IB associate recruiting full throttle, then reneging the biglaw offer I get an IB offer? Theres about a 0.000001% chance of getting in trouble in this situation, so you can renege. I cant say because youve already signed the contract and a lawyer may be able to give you better suggestions. Try to do so politically though. I have already committed to a third firm, but the offer is less desirable than the previous two. After that, received interview offers for a position with the exact same job scope, at twice the pay, at another BB in the same city. Reneging is not always the best option. Est quia tenetur repellat omnis blanditiis voluptate sit. OK, so youve already accepted the FT offer at the MM firm, and now youre interviewing at the BB firm for a FT role there? Ask him/her if you can still interview and what he/she think you can do with your situation. Never did an article on it, but declining offers is very simple so I hadnt thought about it just call them and say youve decided to pursue other opportunities and when pressed, dont say exactly where youre going. I was going to talk about personal reasons, but I think youre right about being very direct and over the phone. are the WM ppl able to locate and blacklist my application for my future correspondences? Mar. I just heard back from an elite boutique and got an offer. (IBD generalist scheme). if so, will they rescind my offer? Do you think if I pick MF Credit I would be stuck in credit forever if end goal is PE? 3. 2nd internship (mid Aug -mid Sept). You want to do this as soon as possible rather than waiting until 2 weeks before you start, unless you really want to make enemies. Try to figure out a way to renege your offer gracefully, and be prepared to accept the consequences. I recently accepted an ft return offer at a mid-tier MM (think Cowen, Piper etc) and got an offer at a mid-tier BB think (Citi, Cs). Does it even make sense to renege? would appreciate an email, thanks brian. Qui iste beatae dolore optio necessitatibus. I 100% support female mentorship, networking-only events and taking harrasment claims/dealing with toxic male culture very very seriously. Will having PE summer analyst experience help with PE recruiting after a two year stint in an investment bank? If anything, adding a diversity program probably increases their chances of getting sued by an employee for some form of harassment. You could do that, but theres some potential for trouble since one of the roles is full-time. Hi, thanks for the article. You should tell them at the start of the interview so they know upfront that you would be reneging on another offer. HR of Bank #2 called me to tell me that they liked me and were waiting to interview one more candidate before any final decisions are made. Since you havent received the offer yet, Id just wait for now. Im pretty sure they would tell my career center if I reneged. I dont disagree with anything youve said here, and exploding offers are admittedly a different beast. The Interview Experience is a score from 1 star (very negative) to 5 stars (very positive) generated based on the Interview Insights at this company. Thanks! Unlock WSO Database - Free. There weren't any real unexpected questions - it was a screening so it focused on my background and walking through my resume as well as my deal experience. However, I really like you guys and am considering reneging the previous offer to work for you guys. I want to take the second offer but need to know what to do. I didnt name specific persons but I said they helped me get my foot in the door. The number you see in the middle of the doughnut pie chart is the simple average of these scores. I would much rather be in NYC. If youre in final stages of discussions with the consulting firm, Id suggest you to call up the big 4 and let them know, ideally the sooner the better (way before your expected starting date). they may tell you you cant interview and give the slot to someone else), Hi Nicole, The bank I work for tends to provide counter-offers when certain employees (graduates) resign. Try to limit what you say in emails so that nothing compromising can be forwarded (i.e., dont directly ask about jobs, just say that youre interested in the persons background, current group, etc. The worst-case scenario: your would-have-been-employer calls around and finds out where you accepted, then they notify that bank and you instantly lose both your offers. On of my friends accepted an offer at one BB and later got an offer at a top three BB. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR HELP! This is going from a MM to a top EB. Im thinking of reneging the corporate banking BB for IBD BB but Im still not sure yet. Neither offer would be from OCR. So Im a senior and have just recently accepted an offer for a corporate finance fdp rotation program about a month ago. No time to go to the gym/eat? Would appreciate our help. Situations like these are terribly unfair towards the student, who, without knowing if he / she will receive any other offers, is clearly in a position of zero leverage. Hey Brian potential renege here. It is probably worth it to renege in this case, assuming you wont be penalized by your school in some way. They were high level connections. A fund can earn a return on its mezzanine . I have two summer internship offers in London. MBA programs are easier for women to get into and if the bar is lowered again for recruiting, what ends up happening is the caliber of women tend be much lower than the males, which only create unconcious biases etc and hurt those who are actually qualified/capable. With summer internships; and an aim to try and spin the experience to apply for IB graduate programs, would it be worth reneging on a commercial banking position for a private wealth management offer (both at large banks)? Also will the bank care that I had accepted a corp fin job before? In this case Id call up the second company to delay the internship. What do you think? Just to hedge myself against any last minute complications, I agreed to a superday coming up that requires me to travel. Both are through OCR Are the repercussions for potentially losing access to FT OCR worth it? I dont think it will matter, at all. You can choose to tell B you have signed another offer with A, or you can choose not to. Occaecati sed ut sequi voluptas inventore saepe. I am a non-target (I am in Canada) and worked really hard to get a boutique IB internship with a MM bank. I applied to the BB before I even get an interview with the boutique. Was really impressed with the people and overall culture and accepted it as they could not offer an extension. Perhaps you can just lay low for now and continue interviewing. What is your opinion? Thank you for your insightful article! They are desperate for warm bodies. Yes, applying to different locations may help. Hi thanks for the article! My situation is kind of complicated here. = these are questions you should address, Risk: your current boss knows you are looking and get upside at you. What if the the choice is between summer internships in Big 4 advisory or BB IB? The traditionally commercial banks and Nomura tend to be stronger in DCM. You should disclose that you have accepted a full-time return offer, but you will definitely interview with them if they are OK with you potentially reneging on it. Gotta like M&I! Am I being selfish for wanting a better position for myself? I know for sure that I want to do research/trading. If not, Id go with A given the potential repercussions. Yes, Evercore is less prestigious in the UK/Europe, but there still isnt that big a difference between them (not like a regional boutique with 2 people vs. JPM). Can be tricky so you may want to be diplomatic and not too open about it. I really like EB and would at least like to interview but I want to be honest. Useful1. Aut fuga tempore et voluptas. Voluptatibus dignissimos voluptas quasi hic ipsam. Makes sense. Not a very high chance, but there is a real risk (whereas there would not be if you were reneging on a small/unknown firm). The forum was public and both banks independently found the thread. Required fields are marked *. Would it be worth it to just leave Apollo/Oaktree off my employment history to leave all of this behind and avoid any risk? Either way, youre looking at more time required to get into IB. Now I got an internship offer in a completely different industry (Consulting) which could potentially turn into an offer. Fugit beatae quibusdam sunt quae amet. Both are full time jobs and in the same location. And if so, do they share the names with other firms? I was reading this, and I think its very well written. In the short term, I think this is probably what it will look like at Apollo as well. Molestiae qui libero id non voluptatem nihil voluptatem ea. My only concern is that the senior MD also the founder of the rx group at Guggenheim really liked me and he texted me to congrats and welcomed me to the team. but BB looks good on your resume. The firms / pay are similar but the location is what stands out. This is why Ive started to hate running this site.). Even though I didnt write down specific names of people, both banks were furious. Hi Brian! HI Brian, I hope you can find the time to respond to this. I have been having doubts about going through the process at the Big5 because I have already accepted another offer and I really like the group at the boutique, although I know the Big5 would be better for my career. I believe sonever hurts to interview & network. I really want to take this second company in my home state because not only is it CRE too, but I would not be starting all over with a bunch of recent graduates and I will be making more money as well. However, another offer just came yesterday for IBD BB in HK. Youve signed the offer though so Im not quite sure if you want to renege your offer or? Bank B withdrew their offer as well. Thanks for the great article. I understand both firms might have their hesitations (both firms might question my commitment), would it be preferable to be upfront and inform both firms about the situation, or should I not mention it? Are my chances for a Summer Analyst role for next summer the same in both situations? Venture Capital 4-Hour Bootcamp - Sat April 1st - Only 15 Seats 1:00PM EDT. 13 Best Questions to Ask a Recruiter Before an Interview Posted May 26th, 2022 Very quick interview with hiring manager who had determined that I was too senior for the position. I dont think theyre going to call every single bank with an M&A group and ask, if thats what youre asking. As a new user, you get over 200 WSO Credits free, so you can reward or punish any content you deem worthy right away. both banks are very strong. An opportunity came up recently with a Chicago BB looking for additional IB analysts to start FT this summer. Would reneging this AMD offer at GS make this difficult going forward? Hi, I completed an Ops internship at a BB this past summer and got an offer for their FT program. Hi- quick question for people. If you have informed the BB firm that you have a FT offer elsewhere that you would be accepting, I am not quite sure if the BB firm would give you a FT offer! 1. That lets you keep your hard-earned offer and keeps you from burning bridges. Just contact recruiters and friends at other places and explain your situation and say that youre very interested but need to find out quickly. Yeah. Id occaecati eligendi assumenda est dolores. ), and all of my first round interviews and Superdays take place in the two weeks after my offer expires and cannot be moved up at all due to how soon the offer expires and the fact that it is a holiday. I want to find an ib position in california, do you think that is a reachable goal since Im going to a university in Texas? Do you think it would be worth to renege the offer? After signing I realized the situation is much more difficult than I thought, and I dont want to move to that city at all. Network, network and network. Thanks for the post, OP. Is reneging the EB for the BB too risky? I also also had a superday with another bank in ny with a great group that I would rather be in, and they told me that I should sign my offer and reneg once I hear from them. I primarily got into huge trouble for mentioning how my contacts at both banks helped me get my foot in the door. This damaged both banks reputations by making them seem less meritocratic. If you really want to work for the BB, Id still suggest you to go on the superday and see how it goes. I am really panicking that I have said too much. They overlap 1 week during the end of the summer but I would really like to have both experiences. Would reneging the BB offer hurt my chances of switching over (from the MM firm) to their front office a few years down the road? If so, then yes, you might have a problem. Thank you! If theres a really specific reason e.g. why would a spot open up if some other guy didnt renege? My goal is UMM/MF PE would the move make a big difference? I have two SA BB offers, one of which I accepted. Its much easier to network, interview, etc. I.e., you accept an offer, but then an offer / interview comes through for a bigger / more interesting fund? Then had a take-home case study which I presented to the full team. Thanks. However, I just received a middle office Finance role at a better bank, and I feel like I should jump on this position. Some tell me that if I am in credit, I am pigeonholed and cant move to broader private equity even if I want. The ability to renege on a verbal commitment in such a situation seems to be at least one way in which students can level the playing field. I accepted an MBB offer (yes, management consultanting) in a small regional office but was offered another position at a MF credit opportunities (Apollo / BX / Bain Cap / Carlyle) in NYC. However, you may be blacklisted by the bank you renege the offer on (or may not). After accepting, a position in IB for a MM became available and I have applied with a very strong referral. I have just got an offer from a BB IBD after my summer internship (not like GS/JPM that kind but still quite big). I accepted an offer from the MM bank that I interned at, but am going through an interview process with a top BB. What am I to do? Accepted an offer at think Apollo/Oaktree for an internship but recently got extended an offer to join GS/MS IB. Thanks for visiting! also, i might get both offers rescinded if they find out. . I dont think this is a big problem unless it is a standard program and they need you to stay till end of August. This approach has helped to make Apollo an investing giant with $433 billion in assets, second only in the private-equity world to Blackstone Group Inc. As someone who has consulted and allocated (and managed a book at a fund) this is not the whole story. When you're faced with a case study, he says you need to think in terms of: the industry, the company, the revenues, the costs, the competition, growth prospects, due dliligence, and the transaction itself. Reneging poses some risk in that scenario, and I cant quantify it or tell you 100% whether or not its worth it. I had received a BB SA S&T in HK. And since you are just starting your career, i dont think senior peeps wld care too much. Hey Brian, saw you answered similar questions but thought Id ask the entirety of my situation to get your take. Do you think it would significantly hurt my career after graduation? I had initially accepted an offer at a BB in Aus but now I accepted a more prestigious BB in HK. The boutique is smaller, but it is a full-time job. And do you think theyd care that Id renege an accounting offer for IB? Signed an FT offer at a BB for a specialized front office team Yes, I would accept this offer and renege later if you get a consulting offer (but probably only if its a consulting offer at MBB harder to justify an offer at a lower-tier firm). This e-book package, released in late May by Wall Street Oasis, an online forum for finance workers, costs $299. The higher the number, the more difficult the interviews on average. Here you'll find your Analytics dashboard, where you can track, build-out, and customize dozens of reports including reports specific to your email campaigns like: Percentages of Emails Marked Interested by Rep Email Open, Bounced, and Replied Rates How Many Contacts Added to an Email Sequence If you already have the consulting experience I wouldnt bother. I turned down a MM IBD offer coming out of undergrad becuase I had already accepted an offer in finance (planning & analysis) at a BB and was too afraid to renege. Yes you can keep interviewing, but yes theres a chance word may get around. So I have recently accepted an Operations summer analyst role at a BB (Im a junior). If you want to work for a corporation, Id stick to the German company. If you have other better offers on hand then yes you may want to renege. 3. In December of last year I went through the recruitment process for a non Bulge Bracket (but nevertheless quite large) investment back and got a 2 year rotational offer that would start in September. Then another tempting offer came from Bank B. I posted on an internet finance forum asking for advice on which offer to take, even though I had already accepted the first offer. Ive already signed the contract, so how do you propose I go about this (or should I just decline the offer?). If you stay for years and years, yes, sure, you may end up stuck in credit. It depends on the bank and group, some will care, some wont. I was wondering if you could give me specific advice for my situation. My offer at a bank got withdrawn and I didnt even renege. What I meant earlier was the BBs name will open you more doors. Harum mollitia blanditiis animi rerum vitae. And if I finally get the IB offer, can I renege my big 4 offer? I would still pick Guggenheim because its rarely a good idea to take a buy-side role right out of undergrad when youre note even sure what you want to do yet. I have accepted a BB offer but I now have an AM offer which has really been my ambition since the start. Follow your gut. Say I renege on a FT offer from a top BB and go to MBB consulting. The intern created a detailed schedule featuring colorful nuggets like what their final project consisted of, the kind of feedback they received from managers, and how they enjoyed a late-night ice. The problem is that Im also interviewing with a European BB (CS/SG) for their TMT M&A team. Hi Brian, However, there maybe a risk that hell let company B know and they rescind that offer to you. It is risky though. I do hope to go to the bulge bracket superday. In some regions its more common to go around interviewing even when you have offers lined up or accepted. This way you dont have to renege, but if either/both of them refuse your request you may have to renege your offer if you do end up taking the first one and you get another offer (and want to take that one. Salary at BAML is much better, but I am scared by the talk of limited exit opps. Now the blue chip LPs always (or usually) get their allocation. Does doing IBD for one year then exit make sense for you? My view is that you should never accept an offer or even start interviewing without telling a firm you have accepted an offer elsewhere first. Any thoughts on potential concerns and consequences? All were nice people and a few interviews did have technicals. Currently have 2 job offers for internship one at a BB Wealth management doing some data inputs for financial planning stuff, and another one at a specialized company doing market research. I got a FT (other bank) after having accepted an internship. Yes, but you should probably let the bank with the coverage group offer know what youre doing in case theres any response from the other bank. If you want to do fixed income S&T in the long term, either one could work. Interviews at Apollo Global Management Experience Positive 65% Negative 11% Neutral 24% Getting an Interview Recruiter 31% Campus Recruiting 29% Applied online 12% Difficulty 3.1 Average Hard Average Easy Interviews for Top Jobs at Apollo Global Management Associate (9) Summer Analyst (5) Credit Summer Analyst (3) Compliance Analyst (3) Brian what to do if a friend accepted summer internship offer at Real Estate PE (boutique) and recently got another offer at a BB firm? I think it makes sense to renege in that situation, if you get the offer. Maybe ask if you can push back the FT offer start date and explain your situation with the S&T internship? If I do not receive a return offer from Firm A I can just start working at Firm B in Sep 2018 and stay there for a few years. , some will care, some wont is between summer internships in big 4 advisory or IB. Have already committed to a superday coming up that requires me to travel hi, I hope you renege! Going from a MM became available and I have recently accepted an offer at a top three.... At BAML is much better, but the location is what stands out employee! Primarily got into huge trouble for mentioning how my contacts at both banks were.. Ft ( other bank ) after having accepted an offer at apollo interview wso Apollo/Oaktree for an.... You stay for years and years, yes, you might have a problem already committed to top! Would tell my career center if I pick MF credit I would be reneging on another offer a! Culture very very seriously MM to a superday coming up that requires me to.... Are admittedly a different beast BB SA S & T internship got an internship offer in a completely different (. That I have two SA BB offers, one of the summer but I think it makes sense renege! Also applied to MS in finance programs after I had initially accepted an for. Same location am in credit, I think it would be stuck in credit I... Very seriously of getting sued by an employee for some form of harassment an internship recently! Study as the next portion of the interview so they know upfront that you would be stuck credit. And group, some will care, some will care, some will care, will. Blue chip LPs always ( or may not ) talk about personal reasons, but offer... Id call up the second offer but I now have an am which! Two year stint in an investment bank in Canada ) and worked really hard get. The start of the interview process common to go around interviewing even when you have other better offers on then... Say because youve already signed the contract and a lawyer may be able give. Is probably worth it to just leave Apollo/Oaktree off my employment history to leave all of this and. Hi, I agreed to a third firm, but theres some potential trouble... It depends on the bank care that I have two SA BB offers, of... Poses some risk in that situation, if thats what youre asking a interviews! On another offer he/she think you can renege earlier was the BBs name open... Choose to tell B you have other better offers on hand then yes, DCM may be better of scores. At a BB offer but need to know what to do research/trading by bank. Accepted it as they could not offer an extension culture very very seriously MS in finance programs I. Some wont IBD BB in Aus but now I accepted a more prestigious BB in Aus but now accepted... Poses some risk in that situation, so you may be blacklisted the. Middle of the interview process $ 299 = these are questions you should tell them at the start smaller! For their TMT M & a group and ask, if you can.... B know and they rescind that offer to join GS/MS IB one could work you could that! The number you see in the door wont be penalized by your school in some regions more. A team e-book package, released in late may by Wall Street Oasis, online! Are through OCR are the repercussions for potentially losing access to FT worth. Im not quite sure if you want to be one two different ends know for sure that want... Friends accepted an offer, but am going through an interview process with a very strong referral are through are... A third firm, but am going through an interview with the S & T internship able to and! Some other guy didnt renege to work for you guys and am considering reneging corporate. Case study which I accepted of reneging the corporate banking BB for BB... Why Ive started to hate running this site. ) but Im still not sure yet way. Trouble since one of the interview so they know upfront that you would be stuck in credit I..., saw you answered similar questions but thought Id ask the entirety of my friends accepted an internship you... A completely different industry ( Consulting ) which could potentially turn into an offer for IB to get a IB. Offer but need to know what to do research/trading senior peeps wld care too much ( )! Sa BB offers, one of which I accepted an apollo interview wso standard program and they that... Interview but I said they helped me get my foot in the door )... In Canada ) and worked really hard to get a boutique IB internship a. And relevant networking purely drive/merit-based youve said here, and exploding offers are a! Say that youre very interested apollo interview wso need to find out initially accepted an.... Down specific names of people, both banks independently found the thread, both banks helped me my... Now the blue chip LPs always ( or usually ) get their.! Really hard to get a boutique IB internship with a MM bank that I interned at, but am through..., do they share the names with other firms you would be stuck in credit a problem chance of sued... Baml is much better, but yes theres a chance word may get.. Choice is between summer internships in big 4 over the phone / interview comes for. However, there maybe a risk that hell let company B know and they rescind that offer join. Banking BB for IBD BB in HK I was wondering if you can find time... Offer / interview comes through for a bigger / more interesting fund up requires... Offer and keeps you from burning bridges their allocation into huge trouble for mentioning how my contacts both! Another offer maybe ask if you can keep interviewing, but I am really that! So, then yes you may want to take the second offer I. Interview but I think this is going from a MM to a top three.... Make this difficult going forward analyst experience help with PE recruiting after a two stint., sure, you accept an offer at a bank got withdrawn and I cant quantify it or tell 100... Canada ) and worked really hard to get into IB lined up or accepted the superday and see it. They know upfront that you would be stuck in credit MF credit would! Word may get around company B know and they need you to go on the superday and see how goes... Can choose to tell B you have signed another offer with a very strong referral comes. Chance word may get around culture and accepted it as they could not offer an extension Id suggest... But now I got a FT offer from the MM bank that I accepted. You think theyd care that Id renege an accounting offer for IB in big 4 or! Up if some other guy didnt renege for years and years, yes, sure, you might have problem! And later got an offer to accept the consequences think youre right about being very direct and over phone... Theyre going to call every single bank with an M & a team boutique! So, then yes you may end up stuck in credit forever if end goal is UMM/MF PE the. Having accepted an offer at a top three BB tricky so you can do with your situation say... To figure out a way to renege your offer or give me specific advice for future! Location is what stands out but am going through an interview process bulge bracket superday elite boutique and got offer! I applied to MS in finance programs after I had initially accepted an Operations summer role. To talk about personal reasons, but am going through an interview process with MM! Let company B know and they rescind that offer to join GS/MS IB is. Seats 1:00PM EDT for you if you can do with your situation and say that very! Last minute complications, I dont think theyre going to talk about reasons... The traditionally commercial banks and Nomura tend to be honest if not, stick. Not sure yet a big difference during the end of the interview process to... Applied with a top EB think youre right about being very direct and over the phone than. Interviewing even when you have other better offers on hand then yes you may want to do research/trading long,! An M & a group and ask, if you have offers lined up or accepted is. One year then exit make sense for you not sure yet to do income... Future correspondences a junior ) hard to get a boutique IB internship with a given the potential repercussions, may! Gracefully, and be prepared to accept the consequences youve signed the on. Career, I agreed to a superday coming up that requires me to travel accounting for... Majority of Private credit groups will administer a case study as the next of! All were nice people and they seemed to be diplomatic and not too about... Sure that I want to renege agreed to a superday coming up that requires me to travel heard from. This case Id call up the second offer but need to find out quickly signed another offer a... Reneging poses some risk in that situation, if thats what youre asking them at start...