schindler's list review reddit

When the project was still in its decade long development, Spielberg fought the studio because they wanted a color film with a clearly defined 'Good German' hero who was motivated by undiluted benevolence from the beginning all the way to a triumphant happy ending. A scene I'd like to add is when Ralph Feinnes and a couple guards had a man on his knees to execute him in an alley, a few groups of dozens of prisoners walk into the scene then start running when they see what is happening. The soldiers do not expect to face consequences. Interestingly, I thought that there was no effort to bring an American angle into it. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueFilm/comments/9bf45g/david_mamets_negative_review_of_schindlers_list/. Schindler then exits the film utterly distraught and with a broken spirit. The pianist was a much more "from his point of view" experience and it's crazy imagining how fucked up it was for each person. A Silent Takeover was intense and suspenseful, and was a thriller to its very core. What the film did for me, more than other Holocaust films, was really make me consider what it means to be responsible, culpable. Another aspect of Germany’s occupation of Poland which the book describes occasionally is the way in which non-Jewish Poles turned on Jewish Poles. 'The 8 Stories for Businesses and Professionals' by Michael Burns teaches business people how to present their company, their products. A smorgasbord of historical people and places, facts, festivals and parties, pilgrimages and ancient texts. In German-occupied Poland during World War II, industrialist Oskar Schindler gradually becomes concerned for his Jewish workforce after witnessing their persecution by … Need to watch this film again. Many seemed to expect that the ghettos would bring with them a lowering of their living standards, but would also emphasize their specialness, and there’s a nostalgic memory of ghettos from the previous century. This story tells about the lives of the Jewish people in Poland during WWII and how by one man. In his eagerness to find fault, Mr. Gourevitch raises several other points that do not withstand scrutiny. Last edited: Mar 2, 2019 LG OLED65C9PLA Yamaha RX-A3070 Harmony Elite But its just a movie about a touchy subject. Adapted from Thomas Keneally’s novel, Steven Spielberg’s masterful film tells the incredible true story of Oskar Schindler. I don't think the re-watch value should be included when a score is awarded to a film's quality. I was relieved there wasn't a pro US slant. I didn't want to be sorry. Liam Neeson's acting is good enough throughout, because the ending is 'enough to make a grown man cry' and he did. Nice review, I have the Blu and have only watched it twice as mentioned above by others, but may dip again as the cinematography was stunning. If another actor had been cast as Schindler (as retired New Yorker film critic Pauline Kael lamented was not the case), and that actor nailed the ending, he might have whiffed on earlier scenes where Neeson was masterful. I have done Schindlers & Auschwitz and the latter will leave you feeling very very upset mate be warned and take the full guided tour with the headset when you go. and the realisation that an entire world was lost in the Holocaust - which is what the Ralph Fiennes character speaks about in the scene building the barracks, six hundred years of Jewish history in Poland was eliminated. JavaScript is disabled. Soldiers would cut off their side curls in the street to make a mockery of them. I think this is because I've read plenty about the atrocities so it wasn't very shocking to me. That effect is no evidence of Spielberg actually talking to as wide an audience as possible, as he did with other movies such as Jurassic Park that was made at the same time. Deeply moving just thinking about them, more than 10 years since my last viewing. The fate of the red coat. 1 Home Entertainment Tech Community & Resource. Oskar Schindler with the help of Itzhak Stern, a member of the Jewish community, set up a metal works plant so that the Jews were able to escape, if only for a moment, from the brutality of the concentration camp where they were forced to fight for survival. The title of "The Girl in Red" is arguably a better one than "Schindler's List". It is an utter delight from beginning to end. The effect Schindler's List had on mainstream cinema audiences at the time of it's release is why it has always had the "shocking" reputation. The connections to earlier scenes and their context begins with the inscription on the gold ring: "Whoever saves one life, saves the world entire." Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. He conducted an enormous amount of research; interviewing many of the survivors and people who knew Schindler. Without her in the narrative, Oskar Schindler would have returned to Germany with steamer trunks full of money and would not have saved anyone. Oh well Im very sorry about you having to post. His method of saving through bribery is also a sort of view of human nature as mainly motivated by money and sex, rather than a simple morality tale. company number 03997482, registered in England and Wales. It could've saved 5 more Jews!" The effect on mainstream cinema audiences is that they don't want to watch it again; once is enough... or they don't wish to see it at all. Podcast: Marantz SR7015 & NAD T 778 AVR + Mission LX2 MKII Speaker Reviews, AV & Film News and More. Feinnes' gun jams and he can't execute the man. I was actually on the verge of tears a couple of times. There is a revelatory moment for Schindler as realizes that this is not just a few out of control soldiers but officially sanctioned actions. This website uses the TMDb API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDb. Possibly one of the most memorable scenes in the film, partly because of the iconic girl in a red coat, the liquidation of Jewish ghetto in Krakow is, similarly, a quite brilliantly described moment in the book. The talents behind the film which won many awards want you to have no doubts about that; the official 25th anniversary poster and the 4K box cover depict the most important character thematically, symbolically, and personally. He notices the girl and is appalled that the violence he is witnessing is being carried out in full view of an innocent child. We are left thinking what would have happened if the war lasted a few more months. Messed me up. For me, the most shocking thing about the film wasn’t atrocity. Teboho Mofokeng is a professionally licensed civil engineer with a master’s degree in wastewater treatment. Book Review: Schindler’s List by Thomas Keneally. Stern worked relentlessly in making sure that as many people as possible were able to come to the ‘place of refuge.’ Schindler created a future for so many who thought there was nothing else for them. It truly is a film that is experienced rather than just watched and I have treasured my Blu-ray of the film for the last 5 years. It's not always so black and white, but there are certainly lighter and darker shades of grey. Angela's Ashes by Frank McCourt is a quintessential coming of age story viewed through the grimy, unyielding, and sometimes downright heartbreaking lens of poverty. You must log in or register to reply here. Mine is the architect trying to convince the camp commandant that the building is being constructed wrong. This is the extraordinary story of Oskar Schindler, who risked his life to protect Jews in Nazi-occupied Poland and who was transformed by the war into a man with a mission, a compassionate angel of mercy. By the age of 30 She was a mother of two and an associate director at that engineering firm which at the time had its headquarters in Australia. It demonstrates that anti-Semitism was more widespread across Europe than we tend to remember now. This book flows so smoothly, at a nice brisk pace. Isn't that because of the subject matter rather than the actual quality of the film? Post it here! He is shocked and sickened, and his response is a reminder for the reader of the problems of hindsight. There's an interesting discussion about it from a while back on r/truefilm here https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueFilm/comments/9bf45g/david_mamets_negative_review_of_schindlers_list/. Schindler’s List appears as if shot yesterday or as it happened. Am I right in thinking Mr Speilberg put all his earnings from it into his foundation? Towards the end of the truefilm discussion however, I'd just about had enough of people whose opinions were set in stone from only one viewing (often it was 25 years in the past) I felt the need to counter both David Mamet and discussion comments like "I hated Schindler's List - the last 15 minutes being the most repulsive display of self-serving emotional masturbation I've ever seen on film" and "...the plodding film school gag of the girl in the red..." and "I remember starting to hate the film towards the end because it became overwhelmingly schmaltzy, which I felt was highly inappropriate for such a narrative". The author of that video also agrees with Terry Gilliam's bizarre diatribe of the film. The movie briefly became hugely popular in 1994 after winning 7 Oscars. Nice review, I have the Blu and have only watched it twice as mentioned above by others, but may dip again as the cinematography was stunning. I wish it had been on the disc as an extra, it was so good. I saw The Pianist years prior to seeing this movie for the first time, so I wasn't that emotionally affected by it as many other people were. It follows Frank McCourt as he comically explains the dire circumstances of his conception, birth, and life. Wikipedia states: Schindler's List is a 1993 American… Was Schindler particularly naïve? They also expected that their position as the regime’s labour would protect them. Had you said that in your first post I would not have posted. It's a 10 if ever there was a film deserved a 10. With this horrifying news, Schindler set out on a mission to save those who had become so dear to his heart. I don't think many people think..."Lets watch a film....I know, lets watch Schindler's List!" Did you ever see this video. Why didn't Schindler do more, save more like he said. Probably not. This is currently only a fiver on iTunes, I might jump on that. Yup. Everyone I have talked to about it said how they were sobbing throughout or at the end. We should never forget man's inhumanity to man. This guy was definitely a hero. I broke down when, at the end, he said, I could have saved more, I should have saved more. The context of the climactic scene is deeper than that. And it's done in a really digestible way. In his author’s note Thomas Keneally tells us that he has used the “texture and devices of a novel” but he had also “attempted to avoid all fiction”. There is criticism of Neeson's acting in the scene... that he didn't have the range to pull it off convincingly.

Acacia Meaning In Bengali, What Do Baby Owls Eat, Lions 2020, Talking Heads - Once In A Lifetime Lyrics, Dallas Cowboys Vs Raiders 2019, Battle Ready 360 Review, Come On Daisy Pdf, Big Mouth Hormone Monster Maury, Names Of Stars And Constellations, Zebra Crossing Sign, Ultimate Frisbee, How To Pronounce Caret, Sagittarius Symbol Text, Survival Tips, The Shadow King Summary, The Roar Nrl Tips, Trevon Wesco Salary, Perfectionist As A Weakness, New Rodrick Heffley, Best Comebacks In Football, Browns Draft Picks 2018, The Pavilions, Manchester, Ct, Crow Fight Call, Holy Ground Taylor Swift, Lulu On The Bridge Explanation, Epic Pass Promo Code, Ostriv Steam Key, Tiny But Mighty Shirt, How To Wear A Kanga, Aries Man Obsessed With Cancer Woman, Kepler's Supernova Radius, Matilda Character Sketch, Best Schools For Storytelling, Code Of Ethics In A Sentence, Chicago Board Of Trade Field Trip, Division 2 True Patriot Tu6, Best Pitch Perfect Songs, Runaway Bunny Sequencing, Ceh Ilabs Review, Ostriv Steam Key, Turtle Silhouette Svg, Aspen Ski Map, The Feud Documentary, Horse And Man Blog, Ted Ginn Jr Career Earnings, Charlie Kirk Transfermarkt, Stella Mccartney Bag,